Marco Island showed up in great numbers at Veterans Community Park on November 11 for the annual Veterans Day Ceremony and the official dedication of the brand-new Vietnam Veterans Memorial. Parking filled up fast, and multiple MIPD officers and volunteers assisted in directing traffic to overflow parking.
The dedication of the Vietnam memorial has been years in the making, and the anticipation was near electric as the crowds pooled in, quickly filling the designated seating areas and spilling over to the grass. Dozens of attendees brought their own chairs, and many remained standing for the entire program.
An estimated 1,000 people attended the ceremony in a beautiful show of support for the men and women who have served our nation selflessly. Veterans of all ages could be seen checkered throughout, in addition to specially assigned seating in a reserved tent.
The memorial remained covered during the program with an authentic T-10 parachute that was primarily used in Vietnam by the troops.
The Lois Kehoe Band played lively tunes as people found seats and sought shade. Both MICMS and MIA students could be seen volunteering, offering water, event programs, and assistance at a special display table featuring real battle-worn articles.
Several local, county, and state leaders and dignitaries were in attendance, along with the presence and high honor of veterans of the 1st and 2nd Battalions of the 7th Cavalry Regiment who served as airmobile infantry units. Some of their infamous combat was chronicled in the book, ‘We Were Soldiers Once…and Young’ by Harold G. Moore and later turned into the major motion picture ‘We Were Soldiers’.
The program began promptly at 11:11 AM with a welcome from William Duncan, US Navy Veteran and Chaplain for the American Legion Post 404. He invited all veterans to stand or raise a hand and as dozens upon dozens answered the call, a surge of respect, admiration, and appreciation could be felt throughout the crowd.
“There are 19.1 million veterans living in the United States. 1,430,000 veterans reside in Florida. Of that, 1,265,000 are male, 163,000 are female. And today we recognize and give thanks to you for your service to this great nation,” said Duncan.
Next, he turned the attention and recognition to a very special era in our history: the Vietnam War.
“From 1955-75, 2,709,918 Americans served in Vietnam. Less than 850,000 are alive today, while, sadly, 58,479 died. This is the reason for this important memorial, to remember and honor those who served in Vietnam and to teach future generations the facts about the war.”
The Marco Island Police Department proudly came forward with the Presentation of Colors; Joe Varano, Major, US Army Veteran, and Trustee of Post 404 led the Pledge of Allegiance, and Maurice LoMonaco, a world-class lyrical tenor, singer and songwriter performed the National Anthem.
Pastor Ed Brant, Brigadier General and US Army Veteran, gave the invocation. “Some were drafted, others volunteered, and many made a long career of service. With today’s dedication of this memorial, we commit ourselves to be grateful for men and women who answered the call.”
Newly re-elected State Representative and US Air Force Veteran, Yvette Benarroch was asked to join the stage as a moving tribute was made to her late husband, American Legion Post 404 member, and all-around beloved piece of Marco Island – Al Benarroch.
“My husband loved this city, and my family and I appreciate all the love and support that you have given us through this difficult time.” She shared that this memorial was the last project that he had worked on and thanked all involved for their work. A moment of silence in remembrance was observed for him.
A traditional American Legion tribute called the POW and MIA table recognition ensued, led by American Legion Post 404 members Rhonda Gloodt, US Navy Veteran, and John Courts, US Army and Navy Veteran.
“A small table, set for one, symbolized the members of the armed forces missing from our ranks. The table is small, symbolizing the frailty of one prisoner alone against an army of suppressors. The table is round, representing the everlasting concern for the missing. The white tablecloth represents the purity of the service members’ intentions in answering the nation’s call. The single red rose in the vase reminds us of the bloodshed for freedom and the love of families waiting at home. The yellow ribbon around the vase represents an unwavering determination to achieve a full account of the missing. A slice of lemon on the plate reminds us of their bitter days. Salt is sprinkled on the plate to remind us of the countless fallen tears of waiting families. The glass is inverted; they cannot toast with us today. The chair is empty; they are not here. The candle is reminiscent of the light of hope, which lives in our hearts to illuminate their way home. The Bible signifies spirit of strength and the faith that holds the same members and their families through poverty, loss, or uncertainty. The American flag represents the supreme sacrifice made for our nation.” Gloodt, whose own father was MIA in the Korean War, spoke with depth and personal connection to the table.
The Lois Kehoe band played a musical salute for all the branches, invoking each branch to stand when they heard their song.
John Apolzan, US Army Veteran and Commander of Post 404, noted the absence of Senator Rick Scott, who was unable to attend due to all senators being kept in Congress over the last several days.
US Army Veteran and Past Commander of Post 404, Lee Rubenstein, took the time to share the story of the memorial’s inception to fruition, from an initial idea scribbled onto a napkin, to seven years of hard work full of bumps, uphill climbs, and obstacles, to its arrival at the park. “I thought it would be historic if Post 404 could create something permanent on Marco Island, something truly special and one of a kind.”
The same bronze sculpting company that created the eagle at the VCP Freedom Fountain was commissioned. Fundraising from the sale of benches and pavers and donations paid for the memorial. “Every donation mattered, large or small. Every contribution represented someone who believed in this project and wanted to be part of something that would last for generations,” said Rubenstein.
The memorial makes history not only Marco Island, but for the nation, as it is the largest bronze cast memorial of the Vietnam War in the United States.
“I wanted the figures to be larger than life. I wanted people to look at these figures and understand that behind every uniform was a real person, a real family, and a story that deserves to be remembered and told,” said Rubenstein.
Shipping delays, dodged import tariffs, and more behind-the-scenes obstacles contributed to the pushing back of the initially intended unveiling, but on Veterans Day – it seemed meant to be.
“May this memorial always remind us that freedom is never free, that our veterans must never be forgotten, and that gratitude should never come too late. To our Vietnam Veterans, from the bottom of our hearts, thank you for your service, and welcome home.” Rubenstein closed.
Apolzan returned to the podium and presented Rubenstein with a special recognition plaque for his years of dedication and service to the Post and the city.
Keynote Speaker, Major General Tim McHale, US Army veteran, followed with an emotionally charged speech invoking all to appreciate the freedoms we hold, which came at great cost to many.
“We are not simply dedicating a beautiful monument of stone and bronze. We are carving a permanent truth, and we are making a sacred promise tangible. We are declaring to every man and woman who served in the jungles, the skies, the waters, the medical treatment facilities, and the hospitals of Vietnam: You are seen, you are honored, and you are finally home.”
“Veterans Day is a time when our nation pauses to express its gratitude to everyone who wore our country’s uniform. We rightly honor all the brave souls of every generation, from the mud of the trenches in Europe, to the frozen ridges of Korea, to the blinding sands of the Middle East. To all those veterans from all the eras who are with us today. Thank you.”
McHale delivered an in-depth look at the daily life of those who served in Vietnam, recapping with vivid clarity. A bond formed between servicemen and women is strong. “They were only Americans, risking their lives, depending entirely on the courage, endurance, and competence of each other.” Upon their return, they were not met with a welcome; instead, “You returned to a nation that was fractured by political division, a nation that too often, tragically and unfairly, confused the war with the warriors.”
“Instead of a celebration, many of you were met in cold silence or, worse, open hostility. For decades, the wounds of the homecoming remained unhealed, but the true measure of your character is that you did not allow the bitterness of the nation to define you or destroy your spirit.” McHale continued with the valiant advocacy that the Vietnam Veterans fought for in the years to come, ensuring that every hero returning from service was met with care and a welcome that they were denied.
“You looked after everyone else. Today, it is our turn to look after you.” He turned to the monument still covered, “This is a monument of your survival, your endurance, and your quiet dignity. When you look at the memorial, we want you to see your own reflection.” He turned to the citizens gathered and stated, “This monument reminds us that our freedom is paid for in the currency of youth, blood, and broken hearts.”
Maurice LoMonaco returned to the mic and sang a touching rendition of ‘God Bless the USA’, inviting all to sing “I’m proud to be an American, where at least I know I’m free, and I won’t forget the men who died, who gave that right to me.”
A description of each statue in the memorial was given by a veteran who either held the position or knew it well:
Lee Ross, US Navy Veteran – Nurse
“More than 6,250 American nurses, the vast majority of them volunteers, deployed to Vietnam. Their average age was 23 years old. Many had less than two years of nursing experience when they stepped off the plane into the heat and chaos of the war zone.
Tens of thousands of Army medics served alongside them and more than 10,000 Navy hospital corpsmen were embedded directly with the main corps.
During the Vietnam War, more than 1,100 Army medics, 645 Navy corpsmen, and eight nurses gave their lives.
Because of their skill, their speed, and their relentless bravery, if a wounded service member reached a field hospital alive in Vietnam, they had a 98% chance of survival.”
Benny Skeldon, US Marine Corps Veteran – Wounded Marine
“When I landed in Da Nang, Vietnam, I took a chopper to Dong Ha and was assigned to the 3rd Battalion, 3rd Marine Division. My first night there, around 2 A.M., I was awakened by ‘Incoming!’, and I was scared to death.
It was the first time I’d ever heard that. I didn’t know what to do, so I just followed the other Marines and dove into the trenches for cover.
Wounded Marines were choppered to the US sanctuary, and KIA were sent in body bags. The wounded Marine statue is an experience that is similar to what I have described.”
Bill Magnus, US Marine Corps Veteran – Radio Operator
“The radio physically adds 26 pounds to your gear that you normally carry in the field, for a total of 50 pounds. Carrying it allowed me and other operators to know what was going on in the company at all times.”
During a helicopter assault in a large field, Magnus was in the first wave. “We all moved toward a tree line under heavy fire. As we moved to the position behind a rice paddy dike, I noticed tracers coming from someone in the trees, so I started shooting. That’s when I learned radio men don’t shoot. Shooting draws fire, as does the antenna, and I’m a strategic target.” If he is hit, there is a hole in their communications. “The antenna not only marks me, it also tells the enemy there’s someone in charge close to me, making them a target as well.
“Company radio operators are untrained. What they know is what they learn through others and their own ingenuity. They’re willing to carry some extra weight in both pounds and responsibility.”
John Cordts, US Navy Veteran – M-60 Machine Gun
“The development of this weapon started in 1940, but it wasn’t until 1957 that it was put in service with the US Army. The M-60 was used with every branch of the service. It can fire various ammunition. Mostly used in Vietnam was the 7.62 x 51 mm bullet. Every fifth round was a tracer of red. The North Vietnamese tracers were green.”
The gun’s nickname was the pig because of its weight of 23 pounds and its firepower of 500-650 rounds a minute. It was hand-carried and on many armaments, making those who held them a primary target for snipers.
The soldier with the M-60 would be the first of his squad to put boots on the ground and then lay down suppression fire to help protect his fellow soldiers.
“Each bandolier that he’s wearing is 25 to 35 pounds, depending on how many rounds. His gear, gun, would be anywhere from 60 to a hundred pounds that he’d be carrying into battle. The gun had a tendency to jam, and the solution was to change out the barrel. He’d also carry duct tape and cable ties, as the gun had a tendency to break down in the harsh Vietnamese weather. The figure here depicted represents a soldier that had been in the field for some time.”
William Duncan, US Navy Veteran – Grenade Launcher
“The M-79 grenade launcher, known as the blooper or the thumper, was a 15-pound, 40 mm grenade launcher that could reach out to over 450 yards.
It was a suppression weapon that the enemy feared. It fired multiple types of munitions, from explosive to incendiary to smoke, which was very important, as tear gas could be used for crowd suppression.
Most platoons had two M-79 grenade launcher people attached to it. It was important in survival, especially when you were outnumbered in the field or didn’t know the numbers or wanted to flush the enemy out of a tunnel, a cave, or some hideout.”
Terry Kehoe, US Army Veteran –
Dog Handler
Scout Dogs and their Handlers walked point as a team, seeking out the enemy. Prince, Kehoe’s five-year-old German Shepherd, and he would join an infantry unit in the field for 10-14 days each time, as then the dog’s acute sense would be waning.
“Prince worked a few meters ahead of me, off leash, and we would search in the jungle, on a path, or even a stream or rice paddies. Scout dog handler teams work quietly so as not to interrupt, alert the enemy. I would communicate with Prince by snapping my fingers and giving them hand signals. When Prince did alert, my job was to interpret what he was telling me, and in what direction.
Prince would sit and raise his ears, sit firmly in place. He would not let me pass him. If I were to try, he would block my way. We would retreat back into the middle of the pack by the radio operator, and the grunts would go forward and clear the area.”
Of the roughly 4,000 military working dogs in the Vietnam War, only 220 returned home. Whether by combat, conditions, or sadly euthanasia, the dogs never reunited with their handlers.
In 2000, Congress passed Robbie’s Law, which continues to allow military working dogs to return to the States and be adopted by their handlers.
Of the approximate 11,000 handlers in Vietnam, 265 were killed, many more wounded.
“The bond between a handler and dog is so enmeshed that many of us have suffered from separation anxiety, which some of us have obtained professional help through the VA.
What came next gave chills to not only to the Vietnam Veterans present, but to all in attendance as Apolzan tapped his ear and asked, “Do you hear that?” he tapped again and looked to the sky, “Here it comes, this is our ride!”
A helicopter, closely resembling the Bell UH-1 Iroquois or ‘Huey ’, flew overhead and circled back in a grand symbolic gesture.
These helicopters were lifelines to those in the field, be it supplies, to get the wounded out, provide backup, ammo, and eventually a ride out.
“16,000 were made; 4,000 of them were shot down in Vietnam. These pilots could land it on a dime in thick tree cover or in open fields.” Apolzan thanked the Lee County Sheriff’s Office for their provision of the chopper.
As the big moment came and the parachute was carefully removed, unveiling the memorial in the dazzling sunlight, the crowds began to encircle it in admiration.
Father Chuck Ruof closed the event with a prayer, and Taps was played by Craig Greusel and Mark Gerbin.
Vietnam veterans were available to answer questions about the statues and if anyone had any Vietnam-related memorabilia, they were encouraged to lay it at the base of the memorial.
It is to be noted that 24-hour surveillance cameras are operational at the memorial.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here