MIA Supporters Pack City Council Meeting About Fate of Baseball Field

Posted
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

An item deep on the May 2 City Council meeting agenda titled Discussion- Staff Recommendation Regarding Tommie Barfield Elementary (TBE) School Interlocal Agreement did not go unnoticed by the people at Marco Island Academy, the island’s public charter high school. It appears the school and its supporters circled the wagons and brought a large contingent to City Hall to let their local officials know how they feel about keeping Tyler Beck Memorial Ballpark at Tommie Barfield Elementary available for use by the island’s youth. It turns out that city council is on their side.

The field is named after a Marco Island youth who was killed while riding his bicycle on San Marco Drive in January of 1995. The park was named in his honor two months later.

Before making a motion to approve the agenda, council chair Erik Brechnitz made a motion to move the agenda item concerning the fate of Tyler Beck Memorial Ballfield at Tommie Barfield Elementary to the top of the agenda.

“I would like to suggest that we move item 12C up to item 8B,” Brechnitz said of the agenda item dealing with the baseball field where MIA practices and plays baseball and practices football. Gulf Coast Little League also uses the field. Council approved unanimously to move the item closer to the top of the agenda.

"This is an agreement between Marco Island and Collier County School District,” said Dan Smith, the city’s director of community affairs. "We had an agreement with Tommie Barfield Elementary that we could use their field for the past 10 years. That agreement is set to expire on July 31. What’s happened over time is use of the field has been limited to more or less Marco Island Academy using it for their programming. And we do have one baseball program that is there. The cost for the maintenance of that field is roughly $30,000. At this point we just feel that the money for the renovation, because we are kind of the middle man, it’s not our field. And we primarily don’t even use it. We think that it should probably go to other agencies. We just don’t want to be in the middle of that. We think our resources are better served in some other recreational programming. This issue was brought up five years ago, and we’re just bringing it up again. I think over time we just don’t have a use for that field anymore.”

“One option would be that we not accept the staff recommendation,” Brechnitz replied, “and we instruct the staff to go negotiate another contract.” 

City Manager Mike McNees then interjected.

“If I could add something to the staff recommendation,” Mike McNees said. “I think it’s really important that staff never had as an objective that MIA not be allowed to continue to play baseball on that field. Samantha Malloy, our parks and rec manager, has had conversations with her counterparts at the school about what an agreement might look like in the future with the city. I know there is some feeling that the baseball team was going to be left out of the shuffle. That was never our intention in any way. But the issue is with this agreement expiring, if we don’t give notice that we want to renegotiate it, we want to look at it and see if there’s a better way, it just renews. The only way to have this conversation was to put this on the agenda and have that conversation.”

“We don’t really have any control over the times we can maintain that,” Smith said, “that’s been shortened. So, we have a short amount of time that we can even maintain those facilities. Programming for Tommie Barfield is number one, and it is according to the agreement."

Councilor Rich Blonna was the first to comment.

“Dan, you remember that I talked to you about this at least a year ago,” councilor Rich Blonna said to Smith. “This is clearly a local agreement between the City of Marco Island and the Board of Education. Not between MIA and the Board of Education. So, we own that. I’m very disappointed in the deal we have with the board of education to be honest with you. That’s the biggest chunk of our taxpayer dollars, supporting the schools. We all pay into this. I don’t think we really get much in return. We don’t have access to the building. In Jersey, where I’m from, I played in a basketball league in the middle school gym for 15 years. It seems that we’re really not getting much out of the deal. And on top of that, we’re paying the maintenance. It seems like a pretty crappy deal to me. I definitely want to keep MIA there. I want them to use that field. I would like to see if we can negotiate with the county to see if we can get more for our taxpayer dollars.”

Vice-chair Jared Grifoni lavished praise on the city’s parks and recreation department and listed a number of their accomplishments. He also noted the large turnout of MIA supporters, students, and staff.

“It’s just really wonderful to see so many people here for this meeting,” Grifoni said. "MIA school folks. Youth sports. I saw some people in jerseys. It’s great that you’re here. It’s unfortunate that it’s under these circumstances. I think maybe it’s a misunderstanding of circumstances more than anything else. But I really hope that you all continue to pay attention and stay engaged and active, because these issues do tend to pop up from time to time. Unless we hear from you, we’re relying on ourselves and anybody else who comes to speak up. So, if you want your voices heard, do what you’ve been doing. Email us and continue to come out to these meetings. It’s tremendously important.

“What we need to do here is to reach out to the district and have a conversation about renegotiating this deal. There’s no circumstances I can see that would justify us eliminating this agreement and letting everyone kind of fend for themselves. As a city we’ve interceded on behalf of the youth of this island a number of times, in respect to the school district and others. Because it’s been tremendously necessary. In the past we’ve had sitting councilors go to school board meetings to trash families and schools on the island. That’s changed 180 degrees. MIA has been in front of us a number of times and has always received support from council. Because we do want to invest in the youth of this community. This is another instance where we need to step up. It’s wonderful to see the kids out there. We want those people to come to this island. If visiting teams are coming here, it’s good for the island. It’s good for our home teams to be able to play on a field they’re familiar with. I was surprised at the recommendation. I understand, I think, the motivation from the staff. I think the way it was referenced, we’re just canceling this agreement, we’re letting it expire. I think it could have been softened a little bit to let people know when they say it for the first time that baseball wasn’t ending on Marco Island. There’s no way that was happening on this council’s watch. But we do need to have these conversations with the district to improve this agreement. I’d be willing to help with this in any way possible, with the staff and the city manager. I think we need to put this to bed early and let everybody go home. Let them know that we’re here and we stand with them. I make the motion that we direct the city manager to reach out to the school district to renegotiate this lease agreement. Some of the factors we want to look at is time, overall control, maintenance costs, future improvements and overall terms of the agreement. Those are the things I would like to look at. That would be my motion."  

Councilor Greg Folley seconded the motion.

Councilor Joe Rola then added his support.

“The district allows us to use, cost-free, non-interfering use of that field,” Joe Rola said, “while we in turn allow them to use, cost-free, all of our fields. You’ve got $32,000 a year in maintenance of this field. The field is used primarily for Marco Island Academy, which is a school. The district is a school system. The district does pay a certain amount for charter school students to go to school. They should have no problem at all in compensating Marco Island for the maintenance that we pay every year for that field. And I think that message should be taken back to them.”

Councilor Becky Irwin appeared to have done her homework on the issue.

“I called one of the school board members,” Becky Irwin said, “I also spoke with the executive director of facilities for Collier County Public Schools. I also got a call from Dr. Kamela Patton, who is the Superintendent of Collier County Public Schools. I spoke with Jane Watt. I wanted to get my arms around what the whole issue is. And there are really no bad guys. Everybody wants the kids to play baseball. The superintendent was very clear that she very much supports baseball on Marco Island. As far as she’s concerned there is no issue or bad blood among them with Marco Island. They don’t have anything negative to say about us whatsoever. But they have a baseball field at an elementary school that they don’t use. Technically they could get rid of that and use it for something else. That could happen. Let’s think about what is actually going on. I would say that we’re in a pretty good position with the agreement that we have. I’m not opposed to going back to the school board and seeing what else there is. But I think for us to actually have access to - and actually have a park for $30,000 a year is not that expensive. I would be in favor of keeping our field and keeping our interlocal agreement, that is really unique among the Collier County School System. And it’s supported by the Collier County School System. They’re for it. They’re very much in favor of it. I’m supportive of the agreement that we have. If there are ways to make it better, for either side, I’m fully for that.”

McNees then weighed in.

“I’d like to make a suggestion,” McNees said, “as Mr. Smith points out, one of the issues we have is how much we’re limited from an access standpoint. It is very difficult sometimes to manage. It occurs to me that it is also an issue for MIA. The suggestion I’m going to make is, if you send me off to meet with the school board to try to find out if we can negotiate terms that can work out for both, I would invite some representative of MIA to attend that meeting. So, they can watch out for their interest as well. Let’s go see them together and talk about how we can come up with a more functional agreement.”

Chairman Brechnitz then put the issue in perspective.

“Let’s not lose a deal because of $30,000. Not that $30,000 is chump change. It just isn’t significantly important. And I’m not convinced it costs us $30,000, frankly. I would like to see the numbers to justify that number. I’m told that Marco Island Academy does much of the maintaining of the infield, striping the lines, putting the bases down, and raking the infield. And we cut the grass. I don’t think it costs us $30,000 a year to cut the grass on that field. That’s my personal opinion. But in any event, let’s not screw it up over $30,000. If that’s what it is, that’s what it is.”

Darrin Palumbo, a former soccer coach at MIA was the first public speaker.

“It sounds like you’re on the right path,” Palumbo said. “I think we need to take a big picture look at what’s happening to the youth on the island. They need green space. They need precedence sometimes at Winterberry Park. The men’s softball players are great, they pay the taxes. But they need to take a night off once in a while so we can have a district championship game. Help the kids. Do everything we can. Help the local kids to have their memorable moments and to create their sports memories.”

MIA athletic director Ryan Marie Roberts then addressed council.

“Our baseball team is about to throw the first pitch in the district semi-final game in Ft. Myers,” Roberts said. "Without the agreement we have in place right now, this team would not be where they’re at right now. A couple of our players sent us a message saying, ‘You fight for us and we’ll fight for you on the field tonight. Our coach, with the help of some parents and players, received the donation of entire roof system at TBE over the structures such as the dugouts, the press box and the sheds. And worked it out well with the TBE principal and leadership team to conduct maintenance - so it can be done. Communication and transparency is key. Our team alone has spent over $3,000 out of their own pockets for necessities for the field.”

MIA principal Melissa Scott then addressed council.

“I just want to make it clear that one club alone at MIA has done 2,500 hours of community service,” Melissa Scott said. "Many of those were for city events. And it’s not because they have to, it’s because they want to.”

Marco Island Academy founder and board president Jane Watt was the next speaker. She had a speech ready but changed her mind about delivering it after hearing from council.

“I prepared a lot of things I was going to say to you,” Jane Watt said. “I’m going to scratch that. I want to thank you for keeping our kids in the forefront. I want to thank you for taking time and consideration and looking for solutions for how we can make things better for our community overall. The people who you see here love children and we love our community. We basically just want to help make things better. We need your help in these matters, because you have more power than we do with the district. But if we work hand in hand, I think we can accomplish great things. I would love to see that ballpark look even better. I think there’s a lot we can do. There’s a lot of potential. We want to be part of the solution, and we’re looking forward to working with all of you to make that happen. I just want to thank you for your consideration and I want to say thank you for thinking about our kids."

Then MIA sophomore Makayla Hendrick spoke. She delivered an impassioned speech about the volunteer efforts of MIA students. Her speech drew polite applause inside council and an enormous uproar from the gallery of MIA supporters who were listening to the proceedings in the foyer.

Following public comment, councilor Greg Folley commented.

“I want to thank everyone from Marco Island Academy and the community for being on hand to support this,” councilor Greg Folley said. "There is no way we’re going to let this slip through the cracks. We’re going to continue it. We’re just going to figure out if we’re going to get a better deal.”

Vice-chairman Grifoni had a final statement before the vote was taken.

“I wouldn’t leave anything off the table,” Grifoni said. "I would have an all-encompassing conversation including costs for lease and even wouldn’t mind seeing what they’d value the entire field at for purchase, as well as hours and accessibility."

Council then voted unanimously to approve Grifoni’s motion. 

 

baseball, sport, marco island academy, field, mia, staff, greg folley, erik brechnitz, jared grifoni, joe rola, naples area, coastal breeze news, marco island florida, marco island, marco news, collier county, swfl, collier news, ryan marie roberts

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here