Many Marco Islanders know Dave Rice from his decades of volunteering on Marco Island. Whether attending a city council meeting dressed as Santa Claus or devising a way to save the Art Center from bankruptcy, the former Marco Island Volunteer of the Year and Citizen of the Year has always made volunteering fun for those giving of their time. But what many may not know about is Rice’s fascinating football career, which ultimately led him to Marco Island. Rice’s football odyssey starts at Hastings High School in Hastings-on-Hudson, New York in the mid-1950s where he was a tall, speedy running back. Rice was good enough to earn a scholarship to play for legendary Ben Schwartzwalder, who had built a powerhouse at Syracuse University around Jim Brown, arguably the best running back in NFL history.
"I wanted to go to Syracuse,” Dave Rice said. "I could run. They were looking for a wide receiver who could catch the ball and run fast. Schwartzwalder told me from the day he talked to me at my mom’s house, ‘We want you to sprint down the field and take as many people with you as possible to open it up for Jim Brown.'”
There was one problem.
"I had an injury, I’ve got a crooked arm,” Rice said, stretching his arms out in front of his body. One arm is noticeably shorter than the other when fully extended. "I wanted to go to Syracuse, I had a scholarship there. My arm locked. I went to rehab and this was the best it got,” he said. "So, I fessed up to coach Schwartzwalder. He was tough. I went to see him and I told him. And I showed him. He said, ‘Well, Dave, I’m canceling your scholarship. But we will help you go somewhere else.' I said, ‘Coach, because of my arm?’ He said, ‘Yeah. There’s no place for a one-armed receiver at Syracuse.’”
Rice was devastated that his coach, who recruited him and promised his mother he'd look after him, was pulling the rug out from under him.
"I was catatonic, actually,” Rice recalls. "He said, ‘That’s the way it is. We’re just canceling it.’ I said, ‘Well coach, I could still be on the team, couldn’t I?’ He said, ‘Yeah, but you won’t be on a scholarship.’”
Rice decided he would stick it out and make the best of it at Syracuse. But his position coach advised him otherwise.
“He pulled me aside and said, ‘Listen Dave, I’m going to tell you right now. I’ve been around here just long enough to know this is no place for you. He will kill you to get you off the team. He’ll make you hold dummies and every other darned thing. He doesn’t have to guarantee you that you’re going to have a uniform. I’m just afraid you’re going to come here and he’s going to run you off one way or the other. I’m telling you he’s mean. I’ve seen him, if an offensive lineman missed a block in practice, he’d say to him, ‘Don’t come to dinner tonight.’”
Rice’s wide receiver coach advised him to try to catch on with a Division II or Division III program. Rice didn’t have to look far.
"The captain on my high school basketball team was going to Ithaca College,” Rice said. "He said, ‘I’m going to my basketball coach, because you’re a basketball player, too. I think you should look at this place.”
Rice followed his teammate's advice and played football and basketball at Ithaca College. But he was soon playing semi-pro football on the side.
“I played in some of these leagues,” Rice said, "they call them semi-pro leagues, while I was in college. Of course, that was illegal. I was pretty well known in the Westchester area. All of a sudden, I was being asked to play. And I was getting $100 a game, plus money to drive down from Ithaca. Sometimes I would play a college game on Saturday and a semi-pro game on Sunday. Everywhere I went I played. And I wasn’t the only one that was doing it. I played every weekend, all through college, making a lot of money. I was driving a Corvette by my second year of college, just from playing in these semi-pro leagues. They called them pro leagues, actually. I played in three or four different leagues. The Metropolitan Football League was comprised of major cities on the east coast. There was the New England League. They were all bonafide leagues. I had a great time. I traveled with this one quarterback, he was asked to be a quarterback for a championship game, and he’d bring me along. We were a team. I had no problems with my arm. Nobody even knew.”
Rice has a file folder full of yellowed clippings from his semi-pro days. It’s clear from the clippings that he was a star on the semi-pro circuit, catching long touchdown passes up and down the eastern seaboard. The leagues, referred to as pro leagues by the newspapers, drew as many as 8,000 fans to their games. Rice’s semi-pro accomplishments were recognized when he was inducted into the American Football Association Hall of Fame 2005. The AFA is dedicated to the advancement and promotion of semi-pro football teams and leagues in the United States.
After graduating from Ithaca, Rice became head football coach and track coach at Greenwich High School, while continuing to play semi-pro football. Greenwich is a powerhouse program in Connecticut that has won 11 state championships and produced eight NFL players, including Pro Football Hall of Fame quarterback Steve Young.
“That’s how it all started,” Rice said. "I loved that place. Steve Young was a quarterback at Greenwich. I was never his coach. I was part of him getting to Greenwich. I was the coach when his father and mother and Steve came in. Steve was a sophomore. His dad was transferred to New York City. They were Mormons, and the closest Mormon church was in White Plains, just about 10 minutes from Greenwich. I was really against having a meeting with the principal. I said, ‘We don’t recruit in high school.’ I guess I was a purist. I said, ‘What is this? Am I selling myself? Am I selling the place or what?' So, Steve Young ended up at Greenwich. I was very surprised.”
Rice’s football playing career ended shortly after he earned a roster spot with the Titans of New York in the fledgling American Football League (AFL). The Titans would later become the New York Jets.
"In 1960, when it started, we were called the Titans of New York,” Rice said. "They contacted me through a coach. I was playing in a semi-pro league, the Metropolitan League. I would drive down and play every Sunday. When the Titans started, their main scout, John Dell Isola was signing players for a team called the Titans of New York. He became my agent/scout. He signed me to play with the team. It was like a semi-pro team. They practiced at night, so I could keep my teaching job in Greenwich. They played in the Polo Grounds, which was less than an hour away. We only practiced three nights a week and played on Sunday. It was fun. It was a little more organized than some of the teams, because it was a better league. I got called in by John Dell Isola one day and he said, ‘Dave, there's a rumor that they’re going to use you as trade bait. The Oakland Raiders are looking for receivers. The Jets are looking for some linemen. They’re looking to trade you.’ I said, ‘Wait a minute, I have a no-cut contract.’ He said, ’That doesn’t mean a thing. Once you sign that contract, they can’t cut you, but they can trade you. They can do anything they want.’ I said, ‘I’m not going to California, I’m getting married. My family is here. So, I just walked away from it all. I was making $16,000 and thought I was making a lot of money.”
It wasn’t long until a new window in football opened for Rice.
"The coach from Columbia, Frank Navarro, always recruited Greenwich High School personally,” Rice said, "because we had such a high academic standing. We had a very good athletic reputation, too. He kept saying to me, ‘Why don’t you come and work for me? Be on my staff.’ I’d always say, ‘Coach, I’m not interested in being a college coach. I can’t see myself calling families in the middle of their dinner hour, trying to get their kid to come to my school.' He said, ‘How about during Easter Break you come down and see if you like it.’ I went down and it was fun. It was basically the same as at Greenwich, but the kids were bigger and older.
"While I was in there, some guy sticks his head in the door and says, ‘Frank, I’d like to see you out in the hall for a minute.’ A few minutes later Frank sticks his head in the door and says, ‘Dave, we’d like to see you out here.’ I thought, ‘Oh, no, did I park in someone’s spot?’ I get out there and it’s the president of Columbia. He says, ‘I know who you are. Frank thinks a lot of you. My best friend is the president of Western Connecticut State University. They want to start varsity football in the university there. I’d like you to call this person, Dr. Haas.' Frank said, ‘Forget about the rest of our meeting, do what he told you to do.’
"I called and it was a woman, Dr. Ruth Haas. She said, ‘Yes, we are definitely going to start football. We want to start it at a competitive level, in Division III. We don’t want to start it at a club level.' I said, ‘That sounds interesting.' She said, ‘I would like to talk to you about it, so I can learn what would be needed.’ I told her I’d be available any time. I said, ‘When would you like to see me?’ She said, ‘How about right now?’ I said, ‘I’m in New York City, it would take me about an hour to get there. I’m only in a coach’s uniform.’ She said, ‘Well, that is what I would think a coach would be wearing. I’ll wait until you get here.’
“I got there at about seven o’clock at night. I thought I was only there to provide information. How many scholarships do you need? How many coaches do you need? How much is it going to cost? I went through the whole routine. I gave her the whole spiel. She said, ‘If you were a candidate for this job, of those things that you think are necessary, and thinking of our school starting off at a grassroots level, what could you live with if you were the coach, to start, then incrementally expand into the ultimate.’ I told her. She said, ’Should we be looking for a name coach?’ I told her I didn’t think that was how she should start. 'I would start by looking for an assistant college coach, who has experience as a coach and as a player. That kind of a guy would know more about the ins and outs of working at a college.' So, I gave her the list. She asked what would be the downside of being a coach there. I told her I thought the biggest downside is the fact that Connecticut is such a small state, and she was a small school. I said, 'It would be very difficult to recruit the kind of players I think you’re going to need in order to win. You don’t want to start, knowing you’re going to lose. There’s not enough good athletes in the state. You’ll have to recruit out of state.' I knew for a fact, from being a high school coach, what it took to get into school there and get in-state tuition. I said, 'You’d use your Pell grants, academic scholarships.' She liked that. I said to myself, ‘Whoever takes this job, this is the kind of lady you want to work for. She’s going to make it happen.'
"Then she said, ‘Would you be interested?’ I said, 'How could I say no? Yeah, sure. I’m not sure I meet all the criteria I just gave you.’ She said, ’They seem to think so at Columbia. I want to offer you the job’”
Rice laughs as he looks back on the scenario. "Can you imagine?” he said. "I got to pick the school colors, the whole bit. I hired my own staff. I hired all coaches from the league that Greenwich was in. We did do very well, although the first year we were 1-7. We had some close games. But the players were all freshmen, and didn't know each other. No one was discouraged. I tried to schedule high end schools, Gettysburg, Merchant Marine Academy, Coast Guard Academy - class schools. I wanted to set a tone for it.”
Rice was surprised when at the end of the season he got a call from a young sportswriter at the Cleveland Press.
"He said, ‘Coach, there are 192 football playing schools in America at all levels. Have you ever heard of the Dunkel System? It ranks every team, from 1-192.’ I knew where this was going. He said, ‘You guys were ranked 192. My editor wanted me to interview the head coach of the worst football team in the country.’ I said, ‘Well, I guess we deserve it. What do you want from me?’ He asked me how I felt about it. I said, ‘I don’t feel good about being number 192, but we did get one, and they’re all new, and they’re all freshmen. And I have some kids. They just need to mature.’ He said, ‘Can you tell me one thing that happened during the season that makes you feel you can count on helping the program grow?’ I said, ‘I do. We were number one in the country in pass defense. We were the best defense in the country against the pass. I have great kids back there.’ He said, ‘I’m going to give you a big plus in my article. How do you think that happened?’ I said, ‘It was easy. Nobody had to throw the football because they ran the ball down our throats.’ He started laughing. He said, ‘I’m going to make sure I make this a very positive article.’”
Rice led Western Connecticut to a pair of 4-7 seasons following his debut season. It was good enough to attract attention from Fordham University.
"Fordham called me,” Rice said. "Their athletic director, Pete Carlesimo, was master of ceremonies at many of the coaching clinics I had attended. I often thought, ‘He must be a great guy to work for.’ They were playing club football, and they had a former Fordham All-American who was their football coach for the club stuff. He didn’t want to do it anymore. So now they were going into Division III. He said, ‘We’re going to be working ourselves up. Since you’re close by, and we know you did what you did in Connecticut, we’re looking for somebody who can start a program, like you did, and build on it. Could you come down and talk to us. I have a committee. I’d like you to come down and meet the committee. We have a lot of questions for you.' So, it was kind of like Dr. Haas.”
Rice made the 35-minute drive to Fordham for what he figured was an informational meeting.
"I went down there on a Saturday morning,” Rice said. "The chairwoman of the committee was Vince Lombardi’s widow, Marie Lombardi. Vince Lombardi was part of Fordham’s Seven Blocks of Granite. They’d never hired him as the head football coach. The mayor of New York was on the committee. Another guy on the committee was Wellington Mara, the owner of the New York Giants. He was a Fordham guy. The president of Fordham was there and a couple of alumni guys. So, I’m in this beautiful boardroom. I thought it was an information only meeting. How did you do it at Western Connecticut? How did you get the kids? I just told them what we did. After the meeting, Mrs. Lombardi said, ‘We’d like you to come back for an interview for the job. We’d like you to come here and spend a weekend.’"
Marie Lombardi showed Rice around the Fordham campus.
"She was my tour guide,” Rice said. "Took me all around the campus. Took me to the locker rooms. They were dilapidated, bad facilities. I had a good feeling that they were interested. I had to meet the committee on Sunday. I had a chance to meet with everybody. Fordham is in Little Italy. One corner is Fordham University, one corner is the botanical garden, the other corner is the Bronx Zoo and the other corner is the hospital. It was a little enclave. A safe enclave. A beautiful campus, like West Point."
The idea was to start at Division III and elevate to Division II or Division IAA. Rice wanted to make sure the alumni were in favor of the plan.
Carlesimo assured Rice that the alumni were very upset with Fordham for dropping football. He assured Rice that they would rally behind him and provide him with great support.
“Carlesimo was also the president of the NIT basketball tournament,” Rice said. "He said ‘If you take the job, I’ll want you to be on the NIT committee. You’ll also be working for Madison Square Garden.' I was on the NIT committee for four years. Traveled all over the world.”
Rice discovered that Carlesimo was not liked by the coaches at Fordham.
"During my time on campus I got a chance to talk to the other coaches,” Rice said. "The problem was, there wasn’t one of them who said anything nice about the athletic director. It was a very tenuous situation. So that was in the back of my mind. I evaluated the whole thing.”
Rice was offered the job at Fordham.
“I said, ‘I’m honored.’ I said, ‘What was my competition like?’ They said, ’There wasn’t any. We liked what you did at a small school. You built it. That’s what we’re looking for, a builder. We’d like to offer you the job. That was in 1975, so I was 35 and I was the 35th head coach at Fordham. “I said, ‘I can’t take it.’ She said, ‘Why not?’”
Rice liked a lot of the package at Fordham, but he wasn’t sure he could win there. He thought back to a lesson he learned at a coaching clinic when he had the opportunity to ask Alabama coaching legend Paul “Bear” Bryant a question.
"I said, ‘Coach Bryant, I don’t know if you have time for me, but I have a question.' He said, ‘What is it?’ I said, ‘If a young coach aspired to think about the future and was trying his best to attain the type of career record you have, what would be your first suggestion on how to start that career as far as taking the right job?' He said, and I’ll never forget it, ’Never go anyplace you know you can’t win. If you don’t succeed in that first job, you probably ought to sell insurance, because it’s hard to go to another job. I used that story when talking to the committee. I said, ‘If I take this job under these circumstances, I know I can’t win.”
"They all said, ‘Why can’t you win here?' I said, ‘It’s all in the facilities. In the recruiting process, you’re talking to a different level of player. They’re going to Michigan, Notre Dame, Southern California. They’re looking at locker rooms with urinals that aren’t three feet tall. The facilities here are awful. They’re antiquated.
“Marie Lombardi said, ’So that’s the only thing you think you’re lacking?’ I said ‘Yes.' She handed me an envelope. Inside the envelope was a check for $6 million. Not for me, for Fordham football. The Vince Lombardi Memorial Athletic Fund. She said, 'We will have the Vince Lombardi Athletic Complex built in three years.’ I said, ‘I’ll take the job, if it’s still an offer after all I said. I’d love to take this job.’"
Rice described Marie Lombardi as feisty.
“She was really feisty,” Rice said. "When I turned it down, she said, ‘You know Dave, Vince Lombardi had one goal in his life that he wasn’t able to achieve. He wanted to be the head coach at Fordham University, but they would never hire him. She said, ‘And you’re turning this job down.’ That’s how I got there.”
Rice enjoyed his time at Fordham.
"From there it was terrific,” he said. "A wonderful place to work. I was there for 10 years. They fired Mr. Carlesimo. I knew he was on his way out. They called me in during my second year as coach. They told me, ‘Mr. Carlesimo is going to be moved from his position to a position in the president’s office.’ They were still in the process of building the Vince Lombardi Memorial Complex. The president said, ‘We want to offer you the job to get you here full time, as the coordinator of intercollegiate athletics. Not the athletic director. I’m thinking that they were going to put me in charge of the new complex. I took the job because it got me on campus full time. I was moved into this big office. I was the athletic director, but I didn’t have the title. So, I was the football coach and the coordinator of intercollegiate athletics. I did that for a year and a half. Then they gave me the title of athletic director. With that, I became a member of the NIT committee, there were six members. So that was a big promotion. I did that until I left."
Rice led Fordham to a 23-13-2 record in his four years as head coach. His final two teams finished 8-2 and 7-3. His 1977 team won the Metropolitan Intercollegiate Conference Championship. He was the MIC Coach of the Year in 1977.
Rice decided to move to Marco Island after 10 years at Fordham. He had discovered the island after being invited by Deltona Corporation when he was still in professional football.
"The Mackle Brothers were targeting professional athletes during their off season,” Rice said. "I had time on my hands. I was on my way out of football anyway. I came down with five other players. They would fly you down. They owned the hotel, so you would stay at the hotel. You got off the plane and they had a little bus for us. We thought they were taking us to lunch. They took us to the sales office. We bought everything. When I showed my mother pictures of the place she started crying. She thought I bought Florida swampland. I bought some lots, I bought a little house and I bought three condos that weekend. The guy who helped me with it was Glenn Tucker, they named City Hall after him. He said I was his first land baron,” Rice said with a laugh. "I wanted to live here as soon as I saw it. They had a model of the island in the sales center. I said, ’What a great spot. This is my ideal.' And everything was cheap. It was just piles of dirt and holes everywhere. I was still living in Westport. It’s something I wanted to have in retirement. It worked out well for us. I bought three condos coming out of the ground at Island Manor. And the reason for it was because they were so close to Residents’ Beach. I bought a two-bedroom house on Dandelion Court. I bought two lots, one on Fieldstone and the other one on Butterfield. It was a tip lot. We all bought stuff and just sat on them. I started renting the condos out, and little by little it paid for everything. Things were cheap in those days.”
Rice’s move to Marco Island was preempted by a persistent college president at FIU. Read more on Rice’s move and his impact on the community in our next edition.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here