Betty Collier Revisited

Posted
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

When Barbara Malta entertained the women’s group at United Church of Marco Island on Tuesday, November 10, she spent an hour transforming herself into one of the island’s first leading ladies, Betty Collier.

“One thing you don’t know,” said Malta, dressed in period clothing and speaking with a Southern drawl, “is my name’s not Betty. No, it’s Elizabeth. I was named after my mom and my mama’s mama. And since there were three Elizabeths in the house, I was nicknamed Betty. And it stuck.”

Malta, who has a background as a Civil War reenactor, had the audience spellbound throughout her portrayal of the island pioneer.

Betty Collier was the wife of William Collier, who many consider the father of Marco Island.

“The man I fell for,” said Malta, as Better Collier, “the man who would change my heart, change my life forever, was William Thomas Collier. He built sawmills. He was not from a wealthy family. They were not prominent, but they were not poor by any means. He had as much education as a county school teacher. He had planned to go to college to be an engineer, but his father had to use his tuition money to pay off a farm loan for his uncle. But without the schooling, William had to go to work. And so he started designing and building sawmills. And he was very good at it. Made quite a reputation for himself in North and South Carolina and even in Georgia.”

It was in Georgia that William and Betty met. They married when William was 34 and Betty 16. Together they had 12 children.

“I promised to be the best wife I could,” Malta told the audience. Eventually the Colliers settled on Marco Island.

“Papa loaded us up and brought us down to Marco Island,” Malta said, “and we went into the Marco River, and we made a sharp right hand turn into what is now called Collier Bay, and that’s where we ended up.”

She said there wasn’t much on the island at that time.

“I stood on the bow of that schooner with the Gulf of Mexico behind me,” she said, “with a beautiful beach, golden sand, and in front of me a swampy mangrove island. I thought to myself, ‘Oh, Lord, how long would we be here?’ Well, ended up being here a long time. The first three things we always thought about when we docked were food, water, and shelter. We sheltered in the schooner. We always had shelter, food. We could always forage and the boys could hunt. Fresh water was always very important. So our older boys, who were older teenagers by the time we got here, went looking for water and they found it. They found fresh water on the island. There was not another settlement on this island for ten whole years. The Barfields came, but they came and settled at Caxambas. And since this was a mangrove island, we never saw them.”

Malta wrapped up her presentation by talking about the Colliers’ son, Captain Bill Collier, who became perhaps the most important of the island’s male pioneer-era settlers.

“Bill, being the loving son that he was, moved back to Marco and took care of us,” Malta said. “Things settled down. He built the first general store on the island. Bill became the first postmaster. He built the Marco Hotel, 20 rooms. Great success. He’s still running that hotel. Pop is still up on the porch, greeting guests. And I cook for the hotel. Oh, I’ve got a roast in the oven! I’m so sorry to keep you. I’ve got to go!” 

Malta, who considers herself the leading expert on the life of Betty Collier, published a book on the island’s famous pioneer in 2020,  titled Betty Collier Marco Island Pioneer.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here