Collier County Commissioners spent the afternoon listening to lawyers’ arguments about whether staff’s go-ahead for the Isles of Capri Food Truck Park was correct under current codes.
FCC Beach and Yacht, LLC’s two appeals sought a ruling by commissioners that the Isles of Capri Food Truck Park is not a permitted use in a C3 zoning district, and a denial of the site development plan.
The afternoon began with a review of the staff’s procedures that resulted in the approval. Staff cited the 2016 Celebration Park decision and usage within the C3 zoning district.
Attorney Richard Yovanovich, on behalf of FCC Beach and Yacht, LLC, argued that staff incorrectly determined that a “Mobile Food Truck” was the same as a “Food Truck Park.” FCC Beach and Yacht, LLC opined that these are two separate entities. Additionally, FCC Beach and Yacht, LLC argued that the property should have gone through a conditional use process, which requires a public hearing.
Attorney Yovanovich took exception to the approval of the Food Truck Park being based on the 2016 decision to allow the development of Celebration Park. Yovanovich argued that the 2016 decision was specific to the Celebration Park project, and should not apply universally. Yovanovich stated FCC Beach and Yacht, LLC’s appeal should be granted in order to allow for a comparable use determination by the developer, to make sure this is appropriate for Isles of Capri.
Attorney Noel Davies, representing developer John Rogers, argued that staff’s approval was correct, as zoning allows for an eating establishment. “If a food park isn’t an eating place, then what is?” said Davies. Attorney Davies argued that the developer has gone through all of the processes that have been approved to date.
The public had their own opinions. Some residents of Bayshore came forward to describe their experience with Celebration Park, with noise complaints being chief among them. Isles of Capri residents voiced concerns over traffic, noise and the impact to the water and environment. Two residents expressed their support of the business venture.
District One Commissioner, Rick LoCastro, spoke first to address issues of safety, noise, traffic, lighting, cohesion with the surrounding area, and most importantly, the wishes of the citizens of Isles of Capri. Commissioner LoCastro said that staff got it right on March 17 when they said there were problems with the Isles of Capri Food Park, and got it wrong when they reversed their decision and approved the Food Park on May 8. Commissioner LoCastro in agreement with FCC Beach and Yacht, LLC’s argument that approval of the Food Park should not be based on the Celebration Park decision. With all that said, LoCastro put forth a motion to grant the appeals from FCC Beach and Yacht, LLC.
Commissioner Burt Saunders agreed, acknowledging that this matter will likely end up in court. Commissioner Saunders stated that there is a noise problem in Collier County, which needs to be addressed and recognized that Isles of Capri is a quiet, residential community. Saunders said that he wouldn’t want to live near this kind of business, agreeing with Commissioner LoCastro that it would destroy the quality of life on the Isles of Capri.
Commissioner William McDaniel, who seconded the motion, expressed his belief that it was too much of a reach to approve something based on what happened in 2016, especially when there is so much more known about the workings of a food truck today than back then. Commissioner McDaniel wants the staff to create a conditional use provision for food truck parks.
Commissioners Andy Solis and Penny Taylor also supported LoCastro’s motion. Commissioner Taylor stated the zoning was only applicable to Celebration Park, and not meant for universal latitude in the entire county.
Commissioner Solis had some questions regarding the legality, but that didn’t affect his support. All commissioners note that this will be appealable by the developer, meaning the courts can overturn the County Commission’s decision on the appeals.
Following their decision, commissioners continued the discussion on regulating food truck parks, recognizing that this issue will not go away. Commissioners agreed that the bar and entertainment noise issue will create the most problems, not the serving of food.
County staff and the County Attorney will come back with proposed regulation suggestions in two weeks.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here